YASA
Donate
Yasa visiting Chmistar- Bekaa, Lebanon. Yasa Conference in collaboration with Renault at Sagesse Ain El Remmeneh Yasa Conference for Civil Defense at Dbayeh Car Crash simulation at AUST university-Achrafieh Brasilia Declaration on Road Safety Yasa and Lassa Conference at the Evengelical Arminian school at Ashrafieh Yasa Conference at LIU rayak Yasa Conference at Balamand-Akkar Up to 27 seconds of inattention after using car's voice commands: studies Yasa Conference for the teachers at Dar Anout Driverless buses being tested in Greece New safety technology leaves some drivers confused Mother of 3 children killed in Vaughan crash Yasa Conference for the chorus of the Lady's rosary camp Ghadir Yasa & Renault Conference in Broummana- Saint Isaiah Monastery Yasa Conference in Akroum Mountain to Al Bayan association What's The Number One Reason People Die Early in Your Country? Americans less satisfied with cars than any time since 2004 Yasa Conference in Ibl El Saki in corporation with the Parish of Saint Georgios Fiat Chrysler recalls more than 85,000 Chrysler 200 sedans New technology will tell drivers when traffic lights change Conference at the association of the Bishop Hanna Tire Pressure and Loading Limits Variable Ride-Height Types of Car Seats Blind drivers go behind the wheel at Spanish racetrack THE NEW SYSTEM OF ROAD TRAFIC MANAGEMENT. Calls for Irish cars to have devices to prevent drink driving London clamps down on dangerous trucks Motorcycle safety the responsibility of riders and drivers Robot kills worker at Volkswagen plant in Germany Former ISU basketball player Jackson Vroman found dead at Calif. home Bus crash in Belgium kills one; UK students all survive Vehicle quality improves overall, but Japanese brands fall behind: J.D. Power Obama proposes tougher mileage standards for heavy-duty trucks The truth about Lebanon’s speed cameras Traffic safety Day at Saint Joseph School Traffic safety Day at Amjad deir Oubil Takata recalls nearly 34M air bags; largest auto recall in U.S. history China: Luxury cars wrecked in 'Fast and Furious' collision Passenger killed in Lamborghini crash at Disney racetrack 'driving experience' Qataris spend millions on 'fancy' licence plates Michael Schumacher Update & Latest News: F1 Racer May Not Return to Normal? DON’T DRINK AND DRIVE TAKE A TAXI TO SURVIVE Mercedes recalling 30,000 cars to fix rear tail lamp problem Canadian soldier, wife, 7-month-old baby killed in U.S. crash Crash car in Ferzoul Bekaa New P.E.I. licence plate in running for best in North America Why Sweden has so few road deaths 96 vehicles involved in collision after 'wall of snow' hits Highway 400 Doctors tell Michael Schumacher's family that 'only a miracle' can save him Man killed while trying to help roll-over victim on Highway 400 Police investigate fatal crash east of city Chris Kattan charged with DUI after freeway crash Busiest speed-on-green camera caught more than 28,000 drivers in 2013 Tests continue for drunk driver charged after allegedly entering liquor store Britain braced for NEW Atlantic storm think twice before you scare someone to DEATH Man hit by train in downtown core Two people dead in Brampton collision Parents of teen killed by drunk driver fight to prevent another tragedy Police hunt hit-and-run driver who left dog walker lying unconscious on the pavement ISF member killed after hitting stray donkey in Safra Japan chemical factory explosion (Mitsubishi) kills at least five Three killed, four injured in Alberta crash 3 Syrian nationals injured in car accident in Tripoli Firefighter finds his daughter dying in crash on Christmas Eve Genting Bus Crash: Worst Tragedy In 2013 Two women extricated from wreckage after car strikes CTrain New Brunswick town grieving loss of 4 teenagers killed in highway crash Unknown car hits and kills Syrian national in Halat RCMP investigate after teen hit in central Alberta Saturday morning snow wreaks havoc on Alberta’s highways Family struggles with loss after alleged impaired driving collision claims Edmonton man Man critically injured after being struck by TTC bus Bus crashes, catches fire in southern India; 45 passengers killed SUV veers into crowd at Beijing's Forbidden City; police say 5 killed, dozens hurt Official: 3 children die in Bronx fire after candle lit Woman in custody in connection to fatal hit and run Sean Edwards killed in Australian crash Police identify 2 Ontario boys killed while crossing street Two Ontario boys killed after being struck by vehicle Man dead after being struck by vehicle in North York. Mexican monster truck kills 8, hurts dozens when vehicle hits crowd. Launch of pilot project in Tunisia. America: Driver dead after car chase from White House to Capitol ends in police gunfire.
Molded in the Shell
10/6/2010 12:11:40 PM

Molded in the Shell


Summary: Helmets whose outer shells are bonded to the foam by putting foam and shell in the mold together are strong and use all of the available space in the shell. This can be a superior technique for making helmets. It permits larger vents, a mixed blessing.

There are various terms for helmets that are molded in one single operation where the outer shell is bonded to the expanding foam. Some are copyrighted phrases. We use "molded in the shell," a generic term. Others use terms like in-mold or in-molded, and Bell has a copyright on the term co-molded.
Manufacturers seem to have as many descriptions for the process as there are terms. Many of them are confusing, so we put up this page.

The process all these terms describe is essentially the same: a thin piece of plastic is placed in a mold, and conforms to the surface. Beads of polystyrene are then added to the mold, it is bolted together and then injected with steam under pressure. The steam expands the polystyrene beads, forming them into the shape of the mold, essentially making a completed helmet. The plastic piece was heated by the steam too, and it conforms very tightly to the expanded polystyrene (EPS) foam. It not only adheres to the foam, but leaves no gaps, filling every available bit of space with foam. You can feel this with your thumb, finding no "beer can effect" when the helmet is molded in the shell.

If all other things are equal, this process can produce a helmet with superior strength. The fusing of the EPS and plastic shell gives the helmet great resistance to cracking from an external blow, and the full-thickness foam liner maximizes the impact management for any given thickness of helmet. Because of the heat, the plastic has to be a higher grade such as GE's Lexan polycarbonate, since the plastics used for helmets with glued-on or taped-on shells would melt in the mold. In addition, a manufacturer can add internal reinforcing in the form of inserts of nylon, plastic or even metal to further strengthen the helmet. All of these innovations make the process much more expensive. Design and labor costs rise and the procedures involved reduce the number of helmets per hour that a single mold can make while sometimes increasing spoilage and rejects.

In a competitive market where few consumers are interested in paying for the safest helmets (as opposed to the sexiest) and fewer still are informed about helmet manufacturing techniques, the additional cost for producing a sophisticated molded in the shell helmet is difficult to recoup in the selling price. So manufacturers tend to reserve those techniques for their more expensive helmets. And the top of the line in recent years has been devoted to bigger vents, slimmer lines and lighter weight.
As the material in the ribs between vents gets slimmer, manufacturers have had to increase the hardness (density) of the remaining foam to provide impact protection. The result is harder foam and smaller surfaces in contact with the head. There is no test in any US bicycle helmet standard for what we call point loading, but it stands to reason that localized loads from impacts are higher with the thinner, harder ribs. That makes no difference at all to a magnesium headform, but to your skull and brain it may. The Australian standard does have a test for localized loading, but we have been unsuccessful in promoting one for the ASTM or CPSC standards used in the US.

In addition, manufacturers dare not advertise that a given helmet is much more protective than their other models. They will be sued if they do, either because the rider was injured in one of their less protective helmets and obviously could have been better-protected, or because the rider was hurt in the most protective model and did not expect that after reading the advertising. That's why you never see such claims in helmet ads in the US.
The result of those competitive, marketing and legal factors is that helmets are not molded in the shell to provide the consumer with superior protection. They are made that way to permit the manufacturer to open up larger and larger vents, and to keep the helmet from breaking up in testing even though the material left between the vents is slim. A helmet with huge vents can be sold at a premium price. A safer helmet cannot.

The period of the best-ever molded in the shell helmets probably occurred in the early 1990's while designs were still very conservative. The molded in the shell helmets of that period were round, smooth, had reasonable vents and only moderately hard EPS. In subsequent years they have evolved into helmets with very large vents and much less foam.
What does all this mean to a consumer? We think you should know that there is no guarantee that a molded in the shell helmet is safer than a cheaper model with a taped-on or glued-on shell. Both will be designed to the same impact standards. In fact, the thicker, softer foam and smaller vents required if the shell is not molded in may make for a safer helmet in low-impact falls or if you are a senior citizen with a more fragile brain. We would like to be more definitive about that, but we do not have any test data to back up our analysis. In short, our advice is that as long as all the helmets you are looking at meet the same CPSC standard, you can buy whatever fits you well, and whatever you think looks and feels good on your head, with the vents you require, regardless of the construction techniques used.

If you still have enough patience for more on what you should be looking for-but may not find-check out our page on the ideal helmet and our page on helmet construction.


Reference:
Bicycle Helmet Safety Institute
4611 Seventh Street South
Arlington, VA 22204-1419 USA

 

YASA

YASA Programs & Trainings

Simulation
Traffic Garden
Driver Improvment Program
First Aid
Books
traning program for the municipality police
Archive YASA
Safety Tips
Defects in field of vision
Safety Promotion
Helmets: How they Work,and What Standards Do
Newsletters
Subscribe to Update
TAF
Victim Support
lfpc
Fire Safety
LASIP
Sport Safety
SBA
Building Safety
SRF
Agriculture Safety
Lassa
School Safety